Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies
Volume 1, Issue 1 , Pages 1-12 , September 2008

A Review of Psychosocial Predictors of Treatment Outcomes: What Factors Might Determine the Clinical Success of Acupuncture for Pain?

  • Felicity L. Bishop

      Affiliations

    • Corresponding Author InformationCorresponding author. Complementary Medicine Research Unit, University of Southampton, Aldermoor Health Centre, Aldermoor Close, Southampton, Hampshire, SO16 5ST, UK
    • ,
  • George T. Lewith

Received 26 February 2008 ,Accepted 5 March 2008.

References 

  1. Breivik H , Collett B , Ventafridda V , Cohen R , Gallacher D . Survey of chronic pain in Europe: prevalence, impact on daily life, and treatment . Eur J Pain . 2006;10:287–333
  2. Burke A , Upchurch DM , Dye C , Chyu L . Acupuncture use in the United States: findings from the National Health Interview Survey . J Altern Complement Med . 2006;12:639–648
  3. Thomas KJ , Nicholl JP , Coleman P . Use and expenditure on complementary medicine in England: a population based survey . Complement Ther Med . 2001;9:2–11
  4. Perry R , Dowrick CF . Complementary medicine and general practice: an urban perspective . Complement Ther Med . 2000;8:71–75
  5. Manheimer E , White A , Berman B , Forys K , Ernst E . Metaanalysis: acupuncture for low back pain . Ann Intern Med . 2005;142:651–663
  6. Thomas KJ , MacPherson H , Thorpe L , Brazier J , Fitter M , Campbell MJ , et al.   Randomised controlled trial of a short course of traditional acupuncture compared with usual care for persistent non-specific low back pain . BMJ . 2006;
  7. Brinkhaus B , Witt CM , Jena S , Linde K , Streng A , Wagenpfeil S , et al.   Acupuncture in patients with chronic low back pain: a randomized controlled trial . Arch Intern Med . 2006;166:450–457
  8. Furlan AD , van Tulder M , Cherkin D , Tsukayama H , Lao L , Koes B , et al.   Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain: an updated systematic review within the framework of the Cochrane Collaboration . Spine . 2005;30:944–963
  9. White P , Lewith G , Prescott P , Conway J . Acupuncture versus placebo for the treatment of chronic mechanical neck pain: a randomized, controlled trial . Ann Intern Med . 2004;141:911–919
  10. Vas J , Perea-Milla E , Mendez C , Sanchez Navarro C , Leon Rubio JM , Brioso M , et al.   Efficacy and safety of acupuncture for chronic uncomplicated neck pain: a randomised controlled study . Pain . 2006;126:245–255
  11. Witt C , Brinkhaus B , Jena S , Linde K , Streng A , Wagenpfeil S , et al.   Acupuncture in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee: a randomised trial . Lancet . 2005;366:136–143
  12. Linde K , Streng A , Jurgens S , Hoppe A , Brinkhaus B , Witt C , et al.   Acupuncture for patients with migraine: a randomized controlled trial . JAMA . 2005;293:2118–2125
  13. Melchart D , Streng A , Hoppe A , Brinkhaus B , Witt C , Wagenpfeil S , et al.   Acupuncture in patients with tensiontype headache: randomised controlled trial . BMJ . 2005;331:376–382
  14. Vickers AJ , Rees RW , Zollman CE , McCarney R , Smith CM , Ellis N , et al.   Acupuncture for chronic headache in primary care: large, pragmatic, randomised trial . BMJ . 2004;328:744
  15. MacPherson H , Thomas K , Walters S , Fitter M . The York acupuncture safety study: prospective survey of 34,000 treatments by traditional acupuncturists . BMJ . 2001;323:486–487
  16. White A , Hayhoe S , Hart A , Ernst E . Adverse events following acupuncture: prospective survey of 32,000 consultations with doctors and physiotherapists . BMJ . 2001;323:485–486
  17. Ratcliffe J , Thomas KJ , MacPherson H , Brazier J . A randomised controlled trial of acupuncture care for persistent low back pain: cost effectiveness analysis . BMJ . 2006;
  18. Witt CM , Jena S , Selim D , Brinkhaus B , Reinhold T , Wruck K , et al.   Pragmatic randomized trial evaluating the clinical and economic effectiveness of acupuncture for chronic low back pain . Am J Epidemiol . 2006;164:487–496
  19. Willich SN , Reinhold T , Selim D , Jena S , Brinkhaus B , Witt CM . Cost-effectiveness of acupuncture treatment in patients with chronic neck pain . Pain . 2006;125:107–113
  20. Wonderling D , Vickers AJ , Grieve R , McCarney R . Cost effectiveness analysis of a randomised trial of acupuncture for chronic headache in primary care . BMJ . 2004;328:747
  21. Kirsch I , Sapirstein G . Listening to prozac but hearing placebo: a meta-analysis of antidepressant medication . Prev Treat . 1998;1:2a
  22. Wampold BE , Minami T , Tierney SC , Baskin TW , Bhati KS . The placebo is powerful: estimating placebo effects in medicine and psychotherapy from randomized clinical trials . J Clin Psychol . 2005;61:835–854
  23. McCracken LM , Turk DC . Behavioral and cognitive-behavioral treatment for chronic pain: outcome, predictors of outcome, and treatment process . Spine . 2002;27:2564–2573
  24. Burton AK , Tillotson KM , Main CJ , Hollis S . Psychosocial predictors of outcome in acute and subchronic low back trouble . Spine . 1995;20:722–728
  25. Wessels T , van Tulder M , Sigl T , Ewert T , Limm H , Stucki G . What predicts outcome in non-operative treatments of chronic low back pain? A systematic review . Eur Spine J . 2007;15:1633–1644
  26. Kaptchuk TJ . The placebo effect in alternative medicine: can the performance of a healing ritual have clinical significance? . Ann Intern Med . 2002;136:817–825
  27. Stewart-Williams S , Podd J . The placebo effect: dissolving the expectancy versus conditioning debate . Psychol Bull . 2004;130:324–340
  28. Kirsch I . Response expectancy theory and application: a decennial review . Appl Prev Psychol . 1997;6:69–79
  29. Benedetti F , Pollo A , Lopiano L , Lanotte M , Vighetti S , Rainero I . Conscious expectation and unconscious conditioning in analgesic, motor, and hormonal placebo/nocebo responses . J Neurosci . 2003;23:4315–4323
  30. Kirsch I . Conditioning, expectancy, and the placebo effect: comment on Stewart-Williams and Podd (2004) . Psychol Bull . 2004;130:341–343
  31. Price DD , Milling LS , Kirsch I , Duff A , Montgomery GH , Nicholls SS . An analysis of factors that contribute to the magnitude of placebo analgesia in an experimental paradigm . Pain . 1999;83:147–156
  32. Mondloch MV , Cole DC , Frank JW . Does how you do depend on how you think you'll do? A systematic review of the evidence for a relation between patients' recovery expectations and health outcomes . CMAJ . 2001;165:174–179
  33. Vlaeyen JWS , Kole-Snijders AMJ , Boeren RGB , van Eek H . Fear of movement/(re)injury in chronic low back pain and its relation to behavioral performance . Pain . 1995;62:363–372
  34. Vlaeyen JWS , Linton SJ . Fear-avoidance and its consequences in chronic musculoskeletal pain: a state of the art . Pain . 2000;85:317–332
  35. Dionne CE , Koepsell TD , Von Korff M , Deyo RA , Barlow WE , Checkoway H . Predicting long-term functional limitations among back pain patients in primary care settings . J Clin Epidemiol . 1997;50:31–43
  36. Hildebrandt J , Pfingsten M , Saur P , Jansen J . Prediction of success from a multidisciplinary treatment program for chronic low back pain . Spine . 1997;22:990–1001
  37. Jellema P , van der Horst HE , Vlaeyen JWS , Stalman WAB , Bouter LM , van der Windt DAWM . Predictors of outcome in patients with (sub)acute low back pain differ across treatment groups . Spine . 2006;31:1699–1705
  38. Smeets RJEM , Vlaeyen JWS , Kester ADM , Knottnerus JA . Reduction of pain catastrophizing mediates the outcome of both physical and cognitive-behavioral treatment in chronic low back pain . J Pain . 2006;7:261–271
  39. Boersma K , Linton SJ . Expectancy, fear and pain in the prediction of chronic pain and disability: a prospective analysis . Eur J Pain . 2006;10:551–557
  40. Dionne CE , Bourbonnais R , Fremont P , Rossignol M , Stock SR , Nouwen A , et al.   Determinants of “return to work in good health” among workers with back pain who consult in primary care settings: a 2-year prospective study . Eur Spine J . 2007;16:641–655
  41. Swinkels-Meewisse IEJ , Roelofs J , Schouten EGW , Verbeek ALM , Oostendorp RAB , Vlaeyen JWS . Fear of movement/(re)injury predicting chronic disabling low back pain: a prospective inception cohort study . Spine . 2006;31:658–664
  42. Poiraudeau S , Rannou F , Le Henanff A , Coudeyre E , Rozenberg S , Huas D , et al.   Outcome of subacute low back pain: influence of patients' and rheumatologists' characteristics . Rheumatology (Oxford) . 2006;45:718–723
  43. Mannion AF , Junge A , Taimela S , Muntener M , Lorenzo K , Dvorak J . Active therapy for chronic low back pain. Part 3. Factors influencing self-rated disability and its change following therapy . Spine . 2001;26:920–929
  44. Woby SR , Watson PJ , Roach NK , Urmston M . Are changes in fear-avoidance beliefs, catastrophizing, and appraisals of control, predictive of changes in chronic low back pain and disability? . Eur J Pain . 2004;8:201–210
  45. George SZ , Bialosky JE , Donald DA . The centralization phenomenon and fear-avoidance beliefs as prognostic factors for acute low back pain: a preliminary investigation involving patients classified for specific exercise . J Orthop Sports Phys Ther . 2005;35:580–588
  46. Altmaier EM , Russell DW , Kao CF , Lehmann TR , Weinstein JN . Role of self-efficacy in rehabilitation outcome among chronic low back pain patients . J Couns Psychol . 1993;40:335–339
  47. Asante AK , Brintnell ES , Gross DP . Functional self-efficacy beliefs influence functional capacity evaluation . J Occup Rehabil . 2007;17:73–82
  48. Lackner JM , Carosella AM . The relative influence of perceived pain control, anxiety, and functional self efficacy on spinal function among patients with chronic low back pain . Spine . 1999;24:2254–2260
  49. Horne R . Representations of medication and treatment: advances in theory and measurement . In:  Petrie KJ ,  Weinman JA editor. Perceptions of Health and Illness . Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Publishers; 1997;p. 155–188
  50. Leventhal HA , Brissette I , Leventhal EA . The common-sense model of self-regulation of health and illness . In:  Cameron LD ,  Leventhal H editor. The Self-regulation of Health and Illness Behaviour . London: Routledge; 2003;p. 42–65
  51. Hagger MS , Orbell S . A meta-analytic review of the common-sense model of illness representations . Psychol Health . 2003;18:141–184
  52. Grotle M , Vollestad NK , Veierod MB , Brox JI . Fear-avoidance beliefs and distress in relation to disability in acute and chronic low back pain . Pain . 2004;112:343–352
  53. Gheldof ELM , Vinck J , Van den Bussche E , Vlaeyen JWS , Hidding A , Crombez G . Pain and pain-related fear are associated with functional and social disability in an occupational setting: evidence of mediation by pain-related fear . Eur J Pain . 2006;10:513–525
  54. Koleck M , Mazaux JM , Rascle N , Bruchon-Schweitzer M . Psycho-social factors and coping strategies as predictors of chronic evolution and quality of life in patients with low back pain: a prospective study . Eur J Pain . 2006;10:1–11
  55. Di Blasi Z , Harkness E , Ernst E , Georgiou A , Kleijnen J . Influence of context effects on health outcomes: a systematic review . Lancet . 2001;357:757–762
  56. Di Blasi Z , Kleijnen J . Context effects. Powerful therapies or methodological bias? . Eval Health Prof . 2003;26:166–179
  57. Cassidy CM . Chinese medicine users in the United States. Part II. Preferred aspects of care . J Altern Complement Med . 1998;4:189–202
  58. Gould A , MacPherson H . Patient perspectives on outcomes after treatment with acupuncture . J Altern Complement Med . 2001;7:261–268
  59. Griffiths V , Taylor B . Informing nurses of the lived experience of acupuncture treatment: a phenomenological account . Complement Ther Clin Pract . 2005;11:111–120
  60. MacPherson H , Thorpe L , Thomas K . Beyond needling—therapeutic processes in acupuncture care: a qualitative study nested within a low-back pain trial . J Altern Complement Med . 2006;12:873–880
  61. Paterson C , Britten N . Acupuncture as a complex intervention: a holistic model . J Altern Complement Med . 2004;10:791–801
  62. Walker G , de Valois B , Young T , Davies R , Maher J . The experience of receiving traditional Chinese acupuncture: a qualitative study involving women with breast cancer having treatment for the menopausal symptoms associated with tamoxifen . Eur J Orient Med . 2004;4:59–65
  63. Bernstein KS . The experience of acupuncture for treatment of substance dependence . J Nurs Scholarsh . 2000;32:267–272
  64. Richardson J . What patients expect from complementary therapy: a qualitative study . Am J Public Health . 2004;94:1049–1053
  65. Kong J , Gollub R , Huang T , Polich G , Napadow V , Hui K , et al.   Acupuncture de qi, from qualitative history to quantitative measurement . J Altern Complement Med . 2007;13:1059–1070
  66. Hughes JG , Goldbart J , Fairhurst E , Knowles K . Exploring acupuncturists' perceptions of treating patients with rheumatoid arthritis . Complement Ther Med . 2007;15:101–108
  67. Ballegaard S , Karpatschoff B , Holck JA , Meyer CN , Trojaborg W . Acupuncture in angina pectoris: do psycho-social and neurophysiological factors relate to the effect? . Acupunct Electrother Res . 1995;20:101–116
  68. Chae Y , Park HJ , Hahm DH , Yi SH , Lee H . Individual differences of acupuncture analgesia in humans using cDNA microarray . J Physiol Sci . 2006;56:425–431
  69. Choi PYL , Tweed A . The holistic approach in acupuncture treatment: implications for clinical trials . J Psychosom Res . 1996;41:349–356
  70. Margolin A , Avants SK , Holford TR . Interpreting conflicting findings from clinical trials of auricular acupuncture for cocaine addiction: does treatment context influence outcome? . J Altern Complement Med . 2002;8:111–121
  71. Norton GR , Goszer L , Strub H , Man SC . The effects of belief on acupuncture analgesia . Can J Behav Sci . 1984;16:22–29
  72. Roscoe JA , Morrow GR , Hickok JT , Bushunow P , Pierce HI , Flynn PJ , et al.   The efficacy of acupressure and acustimulation wrist bands for the relief of chemotherapy-induced nausea and vomiting. A University of Rochester Cancer Center Community Clinical Oncology Program multicenter study . J Pain Symptom Manage . 2003;26:731–742
  73. Schneider A , Enck P , Streitberger K , Weiland C , Bagheri S , Witte S , et al.   Acupuncture treatment in irritable bowel syndrome . Gut . 2006;55:649–654
  74. Schneider A , Lowe B , Streitberger K . Perception of bodily sensation as a predictor of treatment response to acupuncture for postoperative nausea and vomiting prophylaxis . J Altern Complement Med . 2005;11:119–125
  75. Kalauokalani D , Cherkin DC , Sherman KJ , Koepsell TD , Deyo RA . Lessons from a trial of acupuncture and massage for low back pain . Spine . 2001;26:1418–1424
  76. Linde K , Witt CM , Streng A , Weidenhammer W , Wagenpfeil S , Brinkhaus B , et al.   The impact of patient expectations on outcomes in four randomized controlled trials of acupuncture in patients with chronic pain . Pain . 2007;128:264–271
  77. Harborow PW , Ogden J . The effectiveness of an acupuncturist working in general practice: an audit . Acupunct Med . 2004;22:214–220
  78. Meng CF , Wang D , Ngeow J , Lao L , Peterson M , Paget S . Acupuncture for chronic low back pain in older patients: a randomized, controlled trial . Rheumatology (Oxford) . 2003;42:1508–1517
  79. Bausell RB , Lao L , Bergman S , Lee WL , Berman BM . Is acupuncture analgesia an expectancy effect? Preliminary evidence based on participants' perceived assignments in two placebo-controlled trials . Eval Health Prof . 2005;28:9–26
  80. Birch S , Jamison RN . Controlled trial of Japanese acupuncture for chronic myofascial neck pain: assessment of specific and nonspecific effects of treatment . Clin J Pain . 1998;14:248–255
  81. Lao L , Bergman S , Hamilton GR , Langenberg P , Berman B . Evaluation of acupuncture for pain control after oral surgery: a placebo-controlled trial . Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg . 1999;125:567–572
  82. Baischer W . Acupuncture in migraine: long-term outcome and predicting factors . Headache . 1995;35:474
  83. MacPherson H , Mercer SW , Scullion T , Thomas KJ . Empathy, enablement, and outcome: an exploratory study on acupuncture patients' perceptions . J Altern Complement Med . 2003;9:869–876
  84. So DW . Acupuncture outcomes, expectations, patientprovider relationship, and the placebo effect: implications for health promotion . Am J Public Health . 2002;92:1662–1667
  85. Lu DP , Lu GP , Kleinman L . Acupuncture and clinical hypnosis for facial and head and neck pain: a single crossover comparison . Am J Clin Hypn . 2001;44:141–148
  86. Kreitler S , Kreitler H , Carasso R . Cognitive orientation as predictor of pain relief following acupuncture . Pain . 1987;28:323–341
  87. Toomey TC , Ghia JN , Mao W , Gregg JM . Acupuncture and chronic pain mechanisms: the moderating effects of affect, personality, and stress on response to treatment . Pain . 1977;3:137–145
  88. Creamer P , Singh BB , Hochberg MC , Berman BM . Are psychosocial factors related to response to acupuncture among patients with knee osteoarthritis? . Altern Ther Health Med . 1999;5:72–76
  89. Tavola T , Gala C , Conte G , Invernizzi G . Traditional Chinese acupuncture in tension-type headache: a controlled study . Pain . 1992;48:325–329
  90. Karst M , Reinhard M , Thum P , Wiese B , Rollnik J , Fink M . Needle acupuncture in tension-type headache: a randomized, placebo-controlled study . Cephalalgia . 2001;21:637–642
  91. Weidenhammer W , Linde K , Streng A , Hoppe A , Melchart D . Acupuncture for chronic low back pain in routine care: a multicenter observational study . Clin J Pain . 2007;23:128–135
  92. Zaretsky HH , Lee MHM , Rubin M . Psychological factors and clinical observations in acupuncture analgesia and pain abatement . J Psychol . 1976;93:113–120
  93. Wylie KR , Jackson C , Crawford PM . Does psychological testing help to predict the response to acupuncture or massage/relaxation therapy in patients presenting to a general neurology clinic with headache? . J Tradit Chin Med . 1997;17:130–139
  94. Berk SN , Moore ME , Resnick JH . Psychosocial factors as mediators of acupuncture therapy . J Consult Clin Psychol . 1977;45:612–619
  95. Price S , Mercer SW , MacPherson H . Practitioner empathy, patient enablement and health outcomes: a prospective study of acupuncture patients . Patient Educ Couns . 2006;63:239–245
  96. Weidenhammer W , Streng A , Linde K , Hoppe A , Melchart D . Acupuncture for chronic pain within the research program of 10 German Health Insurance Funds: basic results from an observational study . Complement Ther Med . 2007;15:238–246
  97. McManus CA , Kaptchuk TJ , Schnyer RN , Goldman R , Kerr CE , Nguyen LT , et al.   Experiences of acupuncturists in a placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trial . J Altern Complement Med . 2007;13:533–538
  98. Stone DA , Kerr CE , Jacobson E , Conboy LA , Kaptchuk TJ . Patient expectations in placebo-controlled randomized clinical trials . J Eval Clin Pract . 2005;11:77–84
  99. von Elm E , Altman DG , Egger M , Pocock SJ , Gotzsche PC , Vandenbroucke JP , et al.   The Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studies . Ann Intern Med . 2007;147:573–577
  100. Karjalainen K , Malmivaara A , Mutanen P , Pohjolainen T , Roine R , Hurri H . Outcome determinants of subacute low back pain . Spine . 2003;28:2634–2640
  101. Bekkering GE , Hendriks HJM , van Tulder MW , Knol DL , Simmonds MJ , Oostendorp RA , et al.   Prognostic factors for low back pain in patients referred for physiotherapy: comparing outcomes and varying modeling techniques . Spine . 2005;30:1881–1886
  102. Jones GT , Johnson RE , Wiles NJ , Chaddock C , Potter RG , Roberts C , et al.   Predicting persistent disabling low back pain in general practice: a prospective cohort study . Br J Gen Pract . 2006;56:334–341
  103. Skargren EI , Oberg BE . Predictive factors for 1-year outcome of low-back and neck pain in patients treated in primary care: comparison between the treatment strategies chiropractic and physiotherapy . Pain . 1998;77:201–207
  104. Leboeuf-Yde C , Gronstvedt A , Borge JA , Lothe J , Magnesen E , Nilsson O , et al.   The Nordic back pain subpopulation program: demographic and clinical predictors for outcome in patients receiving chiropractic treatment for persistent low-back pain . J Manipulative Physiol Ther . 2004;27:493–502
  105. Groth-Marnat G , Fletcher A . Influence of neuroticism, catastrophizing, pain duration, and receipt of compensation on short-term response to nerve block treatment for chronic back pain . J Behav Med . 2000;23:339–350
  106. White PJ . Attitude and outcome, is there a link in complementary medicine? . Am J Public Health . 2003;93:1038
  107. Dworkin RH , Turk DC , Farrar JT , Haythornthwaite JA , Jensen MP , Katz NP , et al.   Core outcome measures for chronic pain clinical trials: IMMPACT recommendations . Pain . 2005;113:9–19
  108. Devilly GJ , Borkovec TD . Psychometric properties of the credibility/expectancy questionnaire . J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry . 2000;31:73–86
  109. Mao JJ , Armstrong K , Farrar JT , Bowman MA . Acupuncture expectancy scale: development and preliminary validation in China . Explore (NY) . 2007;3:372–377
  110. Vincent C . Credibility assessment in trials of acupuncture . Complement Med Res . 1990;4:8–11
  111. Paterson C , Dieppe P . Characteristic and incidental (placebo) effects in complex interventions such as acupuncture . BMJ . 2005;330:1202–1205

PII: S2005-2901(09)60001-7

doi: 10.1016/S2005-2901(09)60001-7

Journal of Acupuncture and Meridian Studies
Volume 1, Issue 1 , Pages 1-12 , September 2008

Article Tools

* Image Usage & Resolution